Case Study: When “Nobody Can Agree” Is Just Bad Aggregation
Someone Asked Reddit Which Sequels Are Harder Than the Original Games, and According to TheGamer, “nobody could agree.”
That’s not what happened.
What actually happened is something far more boring — and far more common: a clear question got answered, then buried under noise.
The Original Question (Clear, Focused, Mechanical)
Which sequels are significantly more difficult than the first title?
The OP even provided a benchmark example: X-COM: Terror From the Deep — same mechanics, harsher environment, veterans punished.
That establishes clear criteria:
- sequel vs predecessor
- same core systems
- difficulty tuned upward by design
Not vibes. Not DLC. Not “it felt harder when I was twelve.”
What Reddit Actually Did
Out of ~160 comments, the thread split cleanly:
- Legitimate, repeat answers (consensus): Devil May Cry 3 (NA), SMB: The Lost Levels, Zelda II, Advance Wars 2, Halo 2 (Legendary), Metroid Prime 2, Jak II.
These appeared repeatedly, with little disagreement.
- Then entropy set in.
The thread slowly drifted into:
- muscle-memory anecdotes
- DLC comparisons
- accessibility debates
- “going back felt easier” nostalgia
- complexity confused for difficulty
At that point, people weren’t answering the same question anymore — but TheGamer counted that as disagreement.
Noise Is Not Disagreement
People weren’t split on whether DMC3 NA or Lost Levels were harder sequels. They were talking past each other about:
- fairness
- frustration
- personal tolerance
- or just enjoying the sound of their own reply
That’s not “nobody agreeing.” That’s lack of moderation by definition.
The Troll That Proved the Point
To test the waters, I posted a single line:
Dark Souls 2. And not in the way people like to admit.
No elaboration. No insults. No follow-ups.
Predictably:
- “git gud” appeared
- essays appeared
- people assumed my skill level
- nobody addressed the actual metric
I didn’t reply.
That comment was later deleted — not rebutted. Username apparently made mods itchy.
Which is fine. Deletion is still data.
Conclusion
This isn’t “generations crying because games are hard.”
It’s:
- difficulty discourse without definitions
- platforms rewarding noise over precision
- articles mistaking entropy for insight
Reddit didn’t fail to answer the question. It failed to stay on it.
And if a joke with structure gets removed faster than bad faith essays? That tells you everything you need to know about where discourse goes to die.
So yeah.
Fuck Reddit.
—
Filed after review. Logged for future reference. Blog over.